Zakat, the third pillar of Islam, is a mandatory annual charity for eligible Muslims. It serves as a spiritual purification and a vital mechanism for social justice, aimed at alleviating poverty and supporting the vulnerable. A common and important question that arises is whether these funds can be distributed to non-Muslims. The answer, according to Islamic jurisprudence, is nuanced and requires understanding the specific purpose of Zakat versus other forms of charity in Islam.
The General Scholarly Consensus
The overwhelming majority of classical and contemporary Islamic scholars, representing the four major Sunni schools of jurisprudence (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi’i, and Hanbali), maintain that Zakat is intended primarily for Muslims. This position is largely based on the famous hadith (prophetic saying) of Mu’adh ibn Jabal. When the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) sent him to Yemen, he instructed him:
“…Inform them that Allah has enjoined upon them a charity to be taken from their wealthy and given to their poor.” (Narrated by Al-Bukhari and Muslim)
The scholars interpret the pronouns “their wealthy” and “their poor” as referring specifically to the Muslim community. The rationale is that Zakat functions as a unique internal social security system for the Muslim community, strengthening bonds and ensuring that the needs of its own members are met first.
The Qur’anic Categories and a Key Exception
The Qur’an itself specifies the eligible recipients of Zakat in Surah At-Tawbah:
“Zakatexpendituresareonlyforthepoorandfortheneedyandforthoseemployedtocollect[zakat]andforbringingheartstogether[forIslam]andforfreeingcaptives[orslaves]andforthoseindebtandforthecauseofAllahandforthe[stranded]traveler−anobligation[imposed]byAllah.AndAllahisKnowingandWise.”(Qur′an9:60)
While most of these categories are understood to apply to Muslims, one category, “Al-Mu’allafati Qulubuhum” (those whose hearts are to be reconciled or brought together), is widely acknowledged by classical jurists as having included non-Muslims. Historically, funds from this share of Zakat were given to non-Muslim leaders, tribes, or individuals to foster goodwill, encourage them to embrace Islam, or prevent them from harming the nascent Muslim community.
The applicability of this category in the modern era is a matter of scholarly debate. Some scholars, following a decision by the Caliph Umar ibn al-Khattab, argued that this category was suspended as the Islamic state became strong and no longer needed to persuade people in this manner. However, many other classical and contemporary scholars argue that the ruling is not abrogated and can be applied by a legitimate Islamic authority (or a community-based organization in its place) if a genuine benefit for the community can be achieved.
In a contemporary context, some scholars and organizations interpret this category to include:
- New converts to Islam who need support to strengthen their faith.
- Non-Muslims who are sympathetic to Islam or whose support could lead to the betterment and protection of a Muslim minority community.
- Humanitarian outreach to non-Muslims to showcase the compassion of Islam and build bridges of understanding, thereby “reconciling their hearts” to the Muslim community.
The Crucial Distinction: Zakat vs. Sadaqa
It is critically important to distinguish between Zakat and Sadaqa (voluntary charity). While the rules for Zakat are specific, the door for Sadaqa is wide open. There is a firm consensus among all Islamic scholars that it is not only permissible but often encouraged to give voluntary charity to non-Muslims.
This is based on numerous verses in the Qur’an that encourage general benevolence and kindness to all, regardless of faith. For instance, the Qur’an states:
“Allahdoesnotforbidyoufrombeingkindanddealingjustlywiththosewhohavenotfoughtyouoveryourreligionordrivenyououtofyourhomes.Allahlovesthosewhoarejust.”(Qur′an60:8)
Acts of kindness, providing food and shelter, helping a neighbor in need, and contributing to humanitarian causes that affect all people are all highly rewarded forms of Sadaqa.
Conclusion
To summarize, the mainstream and historically established view is that Zakat is a community-focused obligation for Muslims to support fellow Muslims. However, the Qur’anic category of “reconciling hearts” provides a legitimate, albeit debated, opening for giving Zakat to non-Muslims under specific circumstances, often determined by a collective body for the greater good of the community.
For individuals paying Zakat, the safest and most widely accepted practice is to direct their funds to the eligible Muslim categories. For those wishing to extend financial help to non-Muslim friends, neighbors, or humanitarian causes, the highly recommended path is through Sadaqa and other forms of voluntary giving, which Islam strongly encourages as a universal good.
Leave a Reply